Indian Racing Must Learn to Embrace Scrutiny
By Sharan Kumar
Transparency is the foundation of racing integrity,
yet Indian racing authorities often view questions and criticism as threats
rather than opportunities for improvement. With mainstream media coverage
dwindling and access for probing journalists increasingly restricted, the
information vacuum is widening. Australia's approach to open inquiries and
media access offers Indian racing valuable lessons in rebuilding public
confidence.
The integrity of horse racing depends not merely on
ensuring that races are conducted fairly, but also on convincing the public
that they are fair. This distinction is particularly important in a sport where
betting is integral to its existence and public confidence is its most valuable
asset.
Australia offers an interesting example of how racing
authorities can approach this responsibility. Integrity is treated as a
specialised regulatory function, with stewards playing a central role in
monitoring races, investigating suspicious performances, examining riding
tactics and enforcing racing regulations. More importantly, there is an
institutional recognition that transparency is essential to maintaining
confidence.
Racing NSW, for instance, expressly endorses the
conduct of open stewards' inquiries, subject to exceptions where public
hearings could prejudice the rights or interests of those involved. Published
stewards' reports, disciplinary decisions and inquiry findings further enable
the racing public to understand how regulatory decisions are arrived at.
The press is not merely a publicity arm of racing. It
is an important stakeholder with a responsibility to question, investigate and
report. Its presence at objection hearings and other proceedings helps ensure
that decisions are understood rather than simply announced. The media does not
decide the outcome of an inquiry, but its independent observation provides an
additional layer of accountability.
Unfortunately, Indian racing has a very different
institutional culture. Racing authorities have, by and large, not been
accustomed to being questioned. The press is frequently regarded as intruding
into their space, while criticism is interpreted as an attempt to bring the
institution into disrepute. There is an unfortunate tendency to believe that
protecting the reputation of racing means avoiding uncomfortable questions.
This is a fundamental misconception. A good doctor
tells a patient what is wrong, however unpleasant the diagnosis may be. A bad
doctor conceals the ailment, offers reassuring words and allows the disease to
progress until it becomes cancerous. Racing administration should understand
that identifying shortcomings is not an attempt to damage the sport. It is an
effort to prevent problems from becoming chronic.
The consequences of this defensive attitude are
serious. When authorities refuse to explain decisions, when objections and
inquiries are conducted without adequate public access, and when legitimate
questions are met with hostility, suspicion inevitably fills the information
vacuum. Among those who do not follow racing closely, there is a widespread
perception that everything in the sport is manipulated. Whether individual
suspicions are justified is another matter, but the absence of free-flowing
information only strengthens such perceptions.
The problem is compounded by the near disappearance of
legacy media coverage. There was a time when mainstream newspapers had
experienced sports journalists regularly covering racing, questioning officials
and reporting developments beyond the results. Today, in some racing centres,
mainstream coverage is virtually non-existent.
Much of the responsibility for keeping the Indian and
international racing communities informed now rests with just two dedicated
websites. Their contribution to the visibility of Indian racing deserves
recognition. However, there is a distinction between reporting racing
developments and probing its administration. While one largely confines itself
to routine coverage, the other has also attempted to examine governance,
question decisions and investigate issues affecting the sport's credibility.
Such probing journalism has not always been welcomed.
There have been instances of resistance, including denial of access to racing
premises. This is particularly unfortunate when mainstream media has already
withdrawn from the scene. Disagreement with a publication's editorial position
cannot be a legitimate reason to deny it access to information and proceedings
available to the racing press.
A senior Australian racing integrity official who has
followed the developments has offered a particularly relevant perspective. He
observed that the questions raised by the journalist concerned largely obvious
administrative shortcomings rather than personal attacks on individuals. His
central argument was that an organisation must first acknowledge that a problem
exists before attempting to resolve it. Referring to a controversial stewards'
decision at RWITC, he pointed out that the issue was not necessarily whether
the decision was right or wrong, but why the reasons had not been explained to
the racing public. In progressive racing jurisdictions, he noted, such
explanations routinely form part of official stewards' reports. Withholding
information only fuels rumours and mistrust. He also emphasised procedural
fairness when authorities take action against journalists, cautioning that
exclusion without a fair opportunity to respond can seriously damage an
institution's credibility.
His larger observation deserves particular attention:
racing clubs cannot prosper without public interest, and public engagement is
possible only through an appropriate relationship with the press.
Racing authorities must understand that publicity and
journalism are not interchangeable. Publicity highlights achievements;
journalism also examines failures. A sport needs both. A publication must, of
course, be accountable for accuracy and fairness, but criticism cannot
automatically be equated with hostility towards racing.
Indian racing needs a change in attitude as much as a
change in its administrative structure. Accredited journalists should have
reasonable access to objection hearings, stewards' inquiries and other
proceedings of public interest. Detailed stewards' reports should be published
promptly, decisions should be accompanied by reasons, and restrictions on
access should be governed by clear, uniform principles rather than the personal
preferences of officials.
Australia's example demonstrates that openness can be
built into racing administration. India need not blindly replicate another
country's system, but it can certainly adopt the principle that transparency is
a regulatory responsibility, not a concession to the media.
A sport that welcomes praise but resents questions is
not protecting its reputation; it is protecting its comfort. If Indian racing
wants to command public confidence, its authorities must learn to answer
questions rather than resent those who ask them. The credibility of racing
cannot be demanded. It has to be earned, every race day.

Comments
Post a Comment